LEGAL GUIDE · ENGLAND & WALES
One of the most common reasons people talk themselves out of making a personal injury claim is the belief that because they played some part in the accident, they are not entitled to anything. This is a misconception that costs injured people real money every year. In England and Wales, you can make a personal injury claim even if the accident was partly your fault. Your compensation is reduced to reflect your share of the blame — but it is not wiped out entirely.
This legal principle is called contributory negligence, and it is well established under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945. Understanding how it works could mean the difference between walking away with nothing and receiving tens of thousands of pounds.
Not sure whether your circumstances mean you can still claim?
Call us for a free, honest assessment.
Contributory negligence occurs when the person who was injured contributed, through their own actions or inactions, to the accident or to the severity of their injuries. The law recognises that fault is rarely all-or-nothing — in real-world accidents, multiple parties often share some degree of responsibility.
Under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, a court can reduce a claimant’s damages by a percentage that reflects their share of responsibility for the accident. The defendant (the other party) remains liable for their portion.
A pedestrian crosses a road without using the designated crossing and is struck by a driver who was travelling above the speed limit. Both parties share fault. A court might find the pedestrian 25% responsible and the driver 75% responsible. If the pedestrian’s total compensation would have been £20,000, they receive £15,000 — reduced by 25%.
Important point: The defendant will often allege contributory negligence as a tactic to reduce the amount they must pay — even when the claimant’s responsibility is minimal or non-existent. Having an experienced solicitor challenge these allegations is critical to ensuring you are not penalised unfairly.
If the case is contested, a judge makes the final determination of contributory negligence based on the facts and evidence presented. In practice, the vast majority of cases settle through negotiation, meaning solicitors for both sides agree on a percentage reduction without going to court.
The percentage is not arbitrary — it is based on established legal precedents, comparable cases and the specific facts of your accident. Your solicitor will research the case law, challenge any unfair allegations and negotiate the lowest possible contributory negligence finding on your behalf.
Courts assess contributory negligence on the particular facts of each case. A finding of 5% is very different from a finding of 50%. Even a reduction of 25% still means you receive 75% of your full compensation — which on a £30,000 award is £22,500, compared to nothing if you assumed you had no claim at all.
A defendant denying liability entirely — claiming the accident was 100% your fault — is not the same as a finding of contributory negligence. It is a negotiating position, and one that your solicitor is experienced in challenging. If there is credible evidence that the other party was at least partly responsible, your claim has merit regardless of what the defendant initially says.
We have taken on cases where defendants initially denied all liability and successfully established their responsibility through evidence, witness statements and expert reports.
No. If your case is taken on under a Conditional Fee Agreement (no win, no fee), the arrangement remains in place even if contributory negligence is established. You still pay nothing if the claim fails. If it succeeds with a reduced award, the success fee is taken from that reduced figure — you are not left out of pocket.
Speak to a specialist solicitor today
Free, confidential, no obligation
Waivers (also called exclusion clauses) cannot simply override your legal rights in England and Wales. Under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, a business cannot exclude liability for personal injury caused by negligence. Whether a waiver is enforceable depends on the specific wording and context — take legal advice before assuming a waiver blocks your claim.
Not always. In many clear-cut cases — where a driver rear-ended you at a red light, for example — the defendant will not raise contributory negligence because it would have no merit. Where it is raised, your solicitor will assess whether the allegation is valid and challenge it where appropriate.
In theory, if a court found you 100% responsible, you would receive nothing. But that is not contributory negligence — that is a finding that the defendant bears no liability at all. Contributory negligence, by definition, means both parties share fault. If the other party is found to have any degree of responsibility, you will receive some compensation.
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It applies to the law of England and Wales as at June 2026. For advice specific to your circumstances, please contact NJS Law directly.
For a full overview of personal injury claims, including eligibility, time limits and the claims process, see NJS Law’s personal injury claims service page.
Get in touch using the form below or via the following methods:
